next up previous
Next: Statistical Analysis Up: Electron Density and Core Previous: North-South Asymmetries

Empirical Polytropic Law

The radial variations found at high southern latitudes, tex2html_wrap_inline1166 and tex2html_wrap_inline1278 , suggest a polytropic relation between tex2html_wrap_inline1042 and tex2html_wrap_inline1040 in this region, given by tex2html_wrap_inline1036 , with tex2html_wrap_inline1286 ; this is plotted as a solid line in Figure 6. It must, however, be noted that, due to the spacecraft trajectory, the data are acquired roughly across local tubes of force, so that the validity of the polytrope relation is based on the absence of latitudinal and temporal variation inferred in the previous sections. It is also noteworthy that this result refers to a well-defined wind state, i.e., stationary high-speed wind (as shown by the histograms in Figure 7 and in Figure 8) near solar activity minimum, but concerns a limited radial range (1.52 to 2.31 AU).

For comparison, we have plotted in Figure 6 a log-log scatterplot of the electron density as a function of the core temperature and the associated best fit line (dashed-dotted line) from the whole pole-to-pole passage of Ulysses. Since it would be inadequate to determine the slope from a classical linear least squares fitting, because of the finite errors bars on both tex2html_wrap_inline1042 and tex2html_wrap_inline1040 , we used a standard (nonlinear) approach taking into account the uncertainties on both variables [Press et al., 1992] to calculate the tex2html_wrap_inline1176 merit function, the square deviations between measurements and model are weighted by tex2html_wrap_inline1294 , where tex2html_wrap_inline1130 and tex2html_wrap_inline1128 are the measurement uncertainties and tex2html_wrap_inline1038 -1 the slope to be determined, in log-log coordinates. This yields the polytrope relation

eqnarray193

with tex2html_wrap_inline1038 =1.370 tex2html_wrap_inline1304 0.002.

   figure197
Figure 6: Scatterplot of the electron density versus the core temperature from pole-to-pole (170,000 data points). The high concentration of the data at low values of the parameters corresponds to high heliolatitudes where both the electron density and core temperature are low. The dashed-dotted line is the best fit polytropic model tex2html_wrap_inline1036 to the data, with the deduced index tex2html_wrap_inline1038 of 1.37, while the solid line is the relation between tex2html_wrap_inline1040 and tex2html_wrap_inline1042 as deduced from their radial profile southward of tex2html_wrap_inline1026 . The thin gaps in the data are an artefact of our fitting procedure which does not affect significantly the uncertainties of the parameters.

The correlation coefficient between tex2html_wrap_inline1042 and tex2html_wrap_inline1040 is 0.78. Given the number of data points (170,000), the level of significance of that correlation is very high. It is noteworthy that in contrast with the high-latitude data sets considered above and in the other sections, these latter data, obtained in a larger dynamic range, refer to several different types of flow coming from both polar coronal holes, from the vicinity of the heliospheric current sheet and from the associated stream-stream interaction regions. As it can be seen in Figure 1 near solar equator, the most important variation in the electron parameters corresponds to compression due to fast-slow wind stream interactions and coronal transient events.

The value of tex2html_wrap_inline1320 is rather close to the value of 1.47 found by [Feldman et al., 1978a] using tex2html_wrap_inline1042 and tex2html_wrap_inline1324 measured on board IMP 6, 7, and 8 in selected stream-stream interaction regions at 1 AU, two years before the previous solar minimum. [Scudder & Olbert, 1979] argued that the [Feldman et al., 1978a] result might be flawed by a nonuniformity across streamlines. The same may be true of our determination using the whole pole to pole data set, which has very different coronal origins, but not of our determination of tex2html_wrap_inline1326 restricted to the southern high-speed wind; in this latter case, both the density and temperature histograms are roughly Gaussian (as shown in Figures 7 and 8). This latter value of the polytropic index, which is roughly midway between isothermal and adiabatic is still rather different from the polytropic index tex2html_wrap_inline1328 determined by [Sittler & Scudder, 1980], using Voyager 2 and Mariner 10 data acquired in the radial range 0.45 to 4.76 AU at different phases of the solar cycle. However, all these values of tex2html_wrap_inline1038 fall in the wide range 1.1 to 1.7 found recently by [Phillips et al., 1995b] using in-ecliptic observations made by ICE and Ulysses aligned in solar longitude and tex2html_wrap_inline1332 AU apart during the declining phase of a high-speed stream near solar activity maximum.

The large scatter of all those determinations might be due to the fact that they suffer from limited statistics and/or that flux tubes of different origins are mixed (see, e.g., [Schwenn & Marsch, 1991]). This may also mean that the solar wind cannot be described by a single polytropic index independent on heliocentric distance and flow conditions.


next up previous
Next: Statistical Analysis Up: Electron Density and Core Previous: North-South Asymmetries

Karine Issautier
Fri Nov 27 18:47:01 MET 1998