next up previous
Next: Appendix A: Doppler Effect Up: Dispersion of electrostatic waves Previous: 4. Temperature Measurement in

5. Summary and Final Remarks

We have used the spin modulation of the quasi-thermal noise spectrum measured between electron gyroharmonics to deduce the dispersion relation of electrostatic waves propagating roughly normal to the magnetic field. In the frequency range where this can be achieved, which covers a large part of the harmonic bands tex2html_wrap_inline1710 and tex2html_wrap_inline1709 , these measured characteristics are very similar to Bernstein's dispersion curves.

To our knowledge, this is the first time that such dispersion relations are measured in space. Whereas they are relatively easy to measure in the laboratory (see for example [Harp, 1966] and [Ono, 1993] for electron and ion Bernstein waves), these dispersion relations are difficult to measure in space. Previous space measurements were performed by comparing the response of two antennas of different lengths [Filbert and Kellogg, 1988] or by using a single antenna of suitable length [Paranicas, 1993]. Data were only acquired on a small set of isolated frequencies, since these experiments measured narrowband emissions due to instabilities. The present results were made possible by the high sensitivity of the instrument, which allowed us to measure the quasi-thermal noise with minima around tex2html_wrap_inline1714 V tex2html_wrap_inline1098 Hz tex2html_wrap_inline1718 , a level which is still 2 orders of magnitude above the instrument background.

Some limitations to our measurements prevent us from obtaining the dispersion curves in the close vicinity of gyroharmonics: the modulus of the wave vector has to be larger than the inverse of the antenna length in order for the angular pattern to be dependent on it (this excludes frequencies just below gyroharmonics); it must not be too large either, in order that the Doppler shift due to the plasma bulk velocity be sufficiently small (which excludes frequencies just above gyroharmonics). A further limitation is that we only consider weakly damped electrostatic waves propagating roughly across tex2html_wrap_inline1202 . This is expected to be adequate for the present quasi-thermal noise measurements, except, again, in the vicinity of gyroharmonics, where there is a strong damping by thermal electrons.

For most of our dispersion curves, the plasma frequency was measured independently, allowing us to derive from them the electron temperature with a good precision, since it was the only unknown parameter. These results are completely new, compared to the Pioneer and Voyager ones, because it is the first time one gets in situ measurements of electron temperature and density of the IPT outside the vicinity of the centrifugal equator (because of the particular Ulysses trajectory used to drive it out of the Ecliptic plane). They might remain the sole measurements of this kind for a while (in particular, the Galileo spacecraft will have, as Vogager 1, a trajectory close to the torus equator). Densities and comparison with Voyager 1 data were already published by [Hoang et al., 1993], but we give here many more temperature results and improve the precision by more than a factor of 2. These improved measurements allow us to mention the polytropic state law for the electrons in the IPT with an exponent tex2html_wrap_inline1722 . We discuss and interpret this result in a related paper [Meyer-Vernet, Moncuquet and Hoang, 1995].
Finally, we have verified that the small proportion of hot electrons known to be present in the IPT has no significant effect on the dispersion curves considered here. We have also shown that a moderate departure of the bulk cold population from a Maxwellian does not change the shape of the dispersion curves much in the middle of the lowest gyroharmonic bands, which corresponds to the range studied here. With such non- Maxwellian distributions, the dispersion curves depend on an equivalent temperature, which is mainly determined by the less energetic electrons.

The present study might be generalized in several ways. The sensitivity of the antenna angular pattern to the bulk velocity (appendix A) for large values of tex2html_wrap_inline1314 might be used in some cases to measure that velocity. We have not tried to make use of that property, because the achieved precision would not be sufficient to detect the expected small deviation from corotation. One might also try to measure the dispersion relation when the plasma is at the threshold of instability, or unstable, which seems to be the case for a few spectra recorded close to the magnetic equator; such a study might help determine which free energy source is at work in that region. Unfortunately, the limited frequency range of the receiver did not allow us to fully study the harmonic bands near or above the upper hybrid frequency in the IPT (except in one case). One expects in these bands a drop of the plasma quasi-thermal noise between each tex2html_wrap_inline1126 frequency and the following gyroharmonic due to the absence of undamped solution of the dispersion equation in this range. This might be used to detect these frequencies fairly easily in order to deduce the electronic densities along another part of the Ulysses trajectory in the Jovian magnetosphere (M. Moncuquet et al., manuscript in preparation, 1995).


next up previous
Next: Appendix A: Doppler Effect Up: Dispersion of electrostatic waves Previous: 4. Temperature Measurement in

Michel Moncuquet
Tue Nov 18 19:18:28 MET 1997